In this edition, Ben Harper from Luxor Technology shares insights on the evolving landscape of bitcoin mining. Additionally, Colin Harper from Blockspace Media addresses questions surrounding the intersection of mining and artificial intelligence in our Ask an Expert segment.
– Sarah Morton
You’re reading Crypto for Advisors, CoinDesk’s weekly newsletter that provides financial advisors with valuable insights into digital assets. Subscribe here to receive it every Thursday.
Understanding the Shift: Bitcoin Mining Beyond Price Speculation
The investment thesis for bitcoin mining used to be straightforward — miners thrived when bitcoin prices surged and suffered losses when they fell. However, as we approach 2025, this narrative is changing dramatically. The introduction of bitcoin ETFs, the development of hashrate markets, and the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) are revolutionizing the industry, making miners less reliant on bitcoin’s price fluctuations. Here’s an in-depth look at how bitcoin mining has transformed and what this means for investors.
The Divergence in Bitcoin Mining and Price Correlation
In 2023, bitcoin mining stocks acted as a high-beta proxy for the cryptocurrency itself, experiencing amplified movements in tandem with bitcoin’s price volatility. However, this correlation began to weaken in 2024. Despite bitcoin hitting new all-time highs, mining stocks struggled to recover their previous valuations.
The table below illustrates the shifting relationship between the Hashrate Index’s Crypto Mining Index and bitcoin’s price, showcasing weekly price changes throughout 2024.
[Image Placeholder]
Source: Hashrate Index, June 2020 – December 2024
This shift indicates that mining stocks can no longer be treated merely as a reflection of bitcoin’s price. Four significant trends are driving this divergence:
1. Institutional Adoption: The Impact of Spot ETFs
The launch of spot bitcoin ETFs in January 2024 has fundamentally altered the landscape of institutional investment in bitcoin. With these ETFs accumulating over 1.3 million BTC and exceeding $100 billion in assets under management, the attractiveness of mining stocks as a means of indirect exposure has diminished. Instead, capital is now flowing directly into bitcoin, reshaping market dynamics.
2. The Halving Event: New Challenges for Miners
Bitcoin’s fourth halving event in April 2024 reduced the block subsidy from 6.25 BTC to 3.125 BTC, which significantly impacted miners’ primary revenue stream. Historically, price surges following halvings have helped offset reduced rewards; however, miners now face additional hurdles:
– **Increased Network Difficulty:** A record-high network difficulty means that individual miners receive smaller rewards.
– **Declining Transaction Fees:** A drop in demand for blockspace has led to lower transaction fees, which serve as a vital secondary income source.
– **Hashprice Decline:** Despite bitcoin’s 120% price increase throughout the year, the hashprice—a comprehensive measure of mining revenue per unit of computation—plummeted by 75%.
Consequently, miners are grappling with profitability challenges, leading to consolidation and strategic shifts within the industry.
[Image Placeholder]
Source: Hashrate Index
3. The Emergence of Hashrate Derivatives: A New Financial Tool
A transformative development in bitcoin mining in 2024 is the rapid growth of the hashrate derivatives market. This new market allows miners to hedge their future revenue and reduce exposure to bitcoin price volatility, altering their risk management strategies.
Historically, mining revenues were subject to bitcoin’s price swings, complicating cash flow forecasting and financing. With hashrate forward markets emerging, miners can now sell future hashrate production at predetermined prices, stabilizing their revenue streams months in advance. This financial innovation resembles commodity futures in the energy sector, where electricity producers sell power contracts ahead of time to ensure steady income.
In 2024, hashrate forward markets experienced explosive growth, with over-the-counter (OTC) volumes rising by more than 500% year-over-year on Luxor’s hashrate forward market. Additionally, the launch of hashrate futures on Bitnomial marks a significant advancement in regulated exchange trading, offering miners a new financial instrument to enhance their revenue control.
4. The Convergence of Bitcoin Mining and AI: A Strategic Pivot
As mining profitability faces pressure, many firms are turning to AI and high-performance computing (HPC) to diversify their revenue streams. The infrastructure required for bitcoin mining shares important characteristics with AI data centers, both needing substantial power and cooling capabilities. However, transitioning to AI is not without challenges, as the costs associated with AI infrastructure are much higher.
Some mining operations are adopting hybrid models, allocating portions of their computing power to AI workloads while continuing bitcoin mining. Companies like HIVE Digital Technologies, Hut 8, Core Scientific, and Bit Digital are already securing profitable AI contracts to enhance and stabilize their cash flows.
Navigating the Future of Bitcoin Mining
As we look toward 2025, the landscape of bitcoin mining is evolving beyond mere price speculation. The influence of institutional capital, the emergence of hashrate derivatives, and the integration of AI-driven diversification are reshaping the industry. These changes provide miners with innovative ways to manage risk and optimize their revenue.
However, challenges remain, including post-halving pressures, increasing competition, and rising infrastructure costs. Efficiency and adaptability will be crucial for survival in this new environment.
For investors and financial advisors, understanding these shifts is essential. Mining stocks no longer move in unison with bitcoin, and new financial instruments are transforming miners’ operational strategies. As the industry continues to mature, recognizing these structural changes will be vital for navigating future opportunities.
Insights from the Experts
In our Ask an Expert segment, Colin Harper addresses the increasing interest of bitcoin miners in the AI market:
– **Are Bitcoin Miners Serious About AI?**
Absolutely! Since 2022, bitcoin miners have been exploring AI and HPC business lines. Pioneers like Hut 8, Hive, Core Scientific, and Bit Digital have led this shift, with recent developments such as Riot pausing expansions to assess AI opportunities.
– **What Strategies Are Miners Using for AI Transitions?**
Strategies vary significantly among miners. Hut 8 and Bit Digital are acquiring existing data center businesses instead of building from scratch, while Core Scientific is repurposing its existing infrastructure for AI. Each approach has its pros and cons, and the most effective strategies will become clearer over time.
– **Will Miners Continue to Focus on Bitcoin Mining?**
Currently, many miners, including MARA, Cleanspark, and Bitfarms, remain focused on bitcoin mining. Even as they explore AI/HPC opportunities, it’s likely that they will continue mining bitcoin, as the two ventures can be more complementary than competitive.
– Ben Harper, Director, Luxor Technology
Keep Yourself Informed
– The first-ever bitcoin mining ETF has launched, courtesy of Grayscale.
– Sixteen U.S. states are considering bitcoin as a strategic reserve, along with federal interest.
– U.S. crypto and AI czar David Sacks recently addressed regulatory clarity and innovation at a press conference, touching on consumer protection, bitcoin reserves, and stablecoins.
Stay tuned for more insights in the world of cryptocurrency and digital assets.
